Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Hell in Islam, Judaism, Christianity

The Quran states about Hell 

6:128,11:106-108"they shall be in the fire..abiding therein so long as the heavens and the earth endure, except as your Lord please; surely your Lord is the (mighty) doer of what He intends. And as to those who are made happy, they shall be in the garden, abiding in it as long as the heavens and the earth endure, except as your Lord please; a gift which shall never be cut off". 

God attaches the proviso of His will even for those things like heaven and hell which are firmly decreed by Him, "abiding for ever" is made dependent on his pleasure because nothing passes out of His control or authority. He can remove anyone from either heaven or hell, anytime He wishes. Nothing is incumbent upon Him, nothing passes out of His control, His hands are not "tied up" as some among the people of the book provocatively alleged to the prophet 5:64. Even though in that verse 11:106-108 the conditional statements about the length of stay in Heaven/Hell are the same, yet the Quran uses a word that creates a subtle nuance, but with great implications. It refers, only to Heaven as a dwelling place from which the righteous "shall never be cut off" -as it does repeatedly elsewhere such as in 15:48,41:8,68:3,84:25-. This shows that the righteous COULD but WON'T be taken out of it. The verse keeps in view God's complete control over all matters, but also implies that it is by God's grace that one enters paradise in the first place.

In contrast with the subtle nuance regarding Heaven as a gift from which the righteous shall never be cut off, the same verse, in the case of Hell, conveys the idea that some could be taken out at anytime. It says, God does "as He intends". It is interesting noting the Quranic pattern of often contrasting in the same passage, a firm statement regarding the everlasting blissful state of the dwellers of heaven, with an ambiguous description of the ultimate faith of the dwellers of hell. It is the case in 6:128,11:106-108 as shown above, as well as 4:56,121-2,64:9-10,98:6-8.

The root KH-L-D/forever or unchanging, is used in 7:176 to mean that the person will stay on earth in the same unchanging condition for a long timespan, not eternally, with that unchanging condition ending when his own life ends. 

Abada is equally used both in the Quran and Arabic in general for a very long but ultimately lasting time. As stated in Lane's Lexicon Laa ukalimuhu abada/I will not speak to him ever, with ever/abada referring to a state that shall remain until the end of life or as in 60:4 until the end of a condition

 "there will be between us and you enmity and hatred for ever/abada until you believe in Allah Alone". 

Eminent scholars of the past, such as ibn Taymiyya and ibn Qayyim, have argued that 'eternity' or 'forever' are literal, but that literal aspect is confined to the existence of hell itself. This is strengthenned by the fact that not any verse exists that speaks of Hell itself as being eternal, contrary to Heaven. In fact it does say that its fierce fire abates, and that Allah re-ignites it with necessary 17:97. The Quran therefore not only is ambiguous on the timespan of Hell, but also on the fate of those that will finish purging their corresponding punishment therein, whether they will simply be destroyed after or made to enter in to any of the levels of heaven.

In 78:23 the timespan of Hell torture is referred to as ahqaab/ages, where the guilty will experience a 

78:26"Requital corresponding". 

The level and nature of the chastisement will thus be made to parallel with the gravity of the total sins and the far reaching and intricate damages they cause. Such misdeeds may not only be of physical nature, but also spiritual, emotional etc.  There is a reason why the Quran calls Hell an evil cradle/mihad 2:206,3:12,197. It will serve as a place of spiritual cleansing, a process that can be of many different and specific aspects as well as a combination of those aspects, from humiliation 46:20 to spiritual frustration to distancing from God's mercy/laan to physical torture, before one is purged of his sins and then his ultimate fate is left to God. In 85:10 for example it speaks of the punishment in hell as separate from the punishment by the fire. Fire will thus not necessarily be the type of corresponding requital for the earthly misdeeds.

Elsewhere, Hell is referred to as the mother/umm 101:9. This powerful image conveys the idea that the sinner's connection with hell is similar to that of a baby with its mother. Just as a baby draws nourishment from his mother for a time, the sinner will be brought up for spiritual progress in the bosom of hell, for a time. There, a kind of fire will reach to the hearts, the place which is the center of spirituality, to cleanse it from its accumulated rust 104:4-9. Every severe illness needs a time of painful treatment before recovering. Interrupting the treatment would cause a forceful return of the disease. That is why the Quran speaks that should the unrepented sinners be returned to life before being painfully purged of his wickedness, his spiritual disease, he will inevitably plunge back into a life of evil 6:28. The Quran makes it clear that one's earthly spiritual condition will continue in the hereafter, hence the appropriate treatment of that condition. 

It is interesting noting also the use of the word "fitna", implying in classical Arabic the process by which gold is purified through fire. The word is used in the context the hardship humans face in this life, that are actually meant at causing spiritual growth 2:191,29:2,10. The same word is used for the cleansing punishment of hell 37:63. Because one failed going through this difficult refinement process in this world, he will be inflicted with it in the hereafter in a befitting manner. In this life, spiritual refinement is the result of successfully passing the hardship of life with faith in God. This process is impossible in the Hereafter where the veil of the unseen has been lifted. No tests can be issued anymore, neither can one demonstrate sincere penitence, proof of reform, restitution of the harm done to the victim. The only remaining valid purification process is the suffering of the hereafter. 

But in order to stress the long timespan of the punishment, in a place where the sinners' requital will be 

19:79"lengthened"

how does one "lengthen" eternity by the way, the Quran refutes the Jewish notion that the sinners will only dwell in Hell for a short time 

2:80"And they say, "The fire will most certainly not touch us for more than a limited number of days." Say [unto them]: "Have you received a promise from God - for God never breaks His promise - or do you attribute to God something which you cannot know?". 

And just as the Quran cuts short that false, self-serving and wishful thinking concept of short-term chastisement, so does it leave no room to the idea that the punishment itself will be easily bearable. It does so in 21:46 by describing the horrified reaction of one who would be, on judgement day, while still not having entered hell, lightly touched by a relatively "cool" breeze (as compared to the air inside hell). 

None will be able to avert his due stay in Hell as a consequence of moral failings, nor will anyone be able to escape it, bail himself out with riches and avoid a just requital for his deeds 2:167,5:36-37,22:22,32:20. The fact that the punishment of the rejector is an unavoidable reality is pictured in 7:40 which states that the guilty wont enter heaven until the camel passes the eye of the needle, i.e. it is their an unavoidable requital 

"thus do We reward the guilty". 

Again in 41:24,82:16 saying Hell will remain their abode from which they will not be able to absent themselves for an instant regardless of their attitude in it such as bearing the suffering patiently or praying for forgiveness. These verses stress the idea that if someone thinks that in case he does not like the place he will find a way out to escape from it, then he should do away with this conjecture. But in none of these verses is it denied that one may be SET free by God when he has undergone the necessary chastisement, the necessary "trial" with the Fire 51:13-14 or that God may, of His boundless mercy, deliver the sinners when He pleases as stated in 11:107, except for those whom Allah has clearly said that He will not forgive them 4:116. These will have to wait for Allah's justice to be fulfilled in their exceptional case.

Finally, the Quran does not categorically state that Hell is a temporary abode otherwise it would lose its dissuasive strength and people will take the matter "lightly" as the people of the book used to say that Hell will only touch them for a few days 2:80. It must remain a trial and a way, among others, to make the people heed and turn back

 101:9-10,104:5,37:62-65,17:60"a trial for men..and We cause them to fear, but it only adds to their great inordinacy".

The Quran says concerning such concepts of just requital with Heaven and Hell that it isnt a light matter, that it is well considered by the Wise 

4:123"(This) shall not be in accordance with your vain desires nor in accordance with the vain desires of the followers of the Book". 

It further stresses that evil will be JUSTLY and FAIRLY requited 

"whoever does evil, he shall be requited with it, and besides Allah he will find for himself neither a guardian nor a helper". 

The prophetic hadith leaves hope for even the worst of the worst, that they will eventually be admitted to paradise 

"Allah the Exalted will say: The angels have interceded, the prophets have interceded, the believers have interceded, and none remains to intercede but the Most Merciful of the merciful. He will take a handful from the Hellfire and bring people out of it who never did any good and who had been turned into charcoal. He will cast them into a river named the River of Life on the outskirts of Paradise. They will come out as a seed comes cut from the silt carried by the flood. You see it near a stone or tree. Whatever is exposed to the sun is yellow or green, and whatever is under the shade is white...They will come out like pearls with seals on their necks. The people of Paradise will recognize them and say: They are those who have been freed by Allah, whom Allah has admitted into Paradise without any good deeds they have done nor any good they put forward. Then Allah will say: Enter Paradise and whatever you see therein is yours. They will say: O Lord, you have given us favours that you have not given anyone else among the worlds. Allah will say: I have a favour better than this. They will say: O Lord, what thing could be better than this? Allah will say: It is my satisfaction, for I will never be angry with you after this".


The Jewish mainstream belief, only passingly based on scriptures and mainly the results of rabbinical conjectures on oral tradition/Talmud and Zohar is that a dead person's soul rises to heaven immediately for judgement. Those of exceptional righteousness, a very small percentage of the whole, remain in it but others descend to gehonnim (sometimes called sheol) to undergo a "cleansing" treatment that is more or less painful depending on the degree of earthly transgressions, of up to 1 year, in any of its 7 levels that are like prisons where the sinners are "visited" by their sins (see Rashi on Isa24:22). Those earthly sins take the form of punishing angels, visiting the guilty with the corresponding chastisement. The nature of that punishment is unknown but the Talmudic rabbis unambiguously speak of torture and pain, regardless of whether chastisement and death have already been inflicted in this world (see Rashi on 1Kings2:6,Mal3:6,Ecc7:13). The notion of 3 categories of souls (righteous, intermediate, sinful), as well as the purification of the intermediate group is hinted at in Zech13:9. Other rabbinical opinions state that the 3 categories are in fact among several other aspects within every soul; the higher "aspect" of the soul, the neshama immediately experiences bliss in Gan Eden where it unites with God, while the lower one undergoes a painful purification process. The "nefesh", the aspect of the soul solely concerned with worldly, physical needs, remains in the grave within the body to experience the necessary suffering. Simultaneous suffering is inflicted upon the "ruach" another of the soul's aspects, in gehonnim.

Returning to the mainstream belief, as each soul's cleansing process completes, it waits in a relatively pleasant place called the realm of souls, until the ushering of the messianic age, in this very world, where they are resurrected. In that utopian world called olam ha-ba, now ruled by the promised prophet-king-messiah, and where Judaism forcefully dominates all nations and beliefs, they start reaping their allotted portion of rewards. The rabbis disagree after that point on whether the messianic world continues eternally or eventually ends after all people have seen, assimilated and accepted the "perfection" of a Jewish world order. At the eventual end of the messianic era, the souls leave the bodies that return to dust, and go to heaven/Gan Eden where they experience their reward completely and eternally. Gan Eden isnt the place where Adam and Eve were, rather a place of spiritual perfection. It could be the place where early Jewish writings hint that certain righteous souls are gathered Gen25:8,17,35:29,49:33,Deut32:50. 

The worst sinners' souls, a small percentage of the whole as in the case of the most righteous, simply vanish following their 1 year at gehonnim, do not resurrect nor experience any share of the perfect messianic world as well as the heavenly abode. Other opinions state that following the initial 1 year stay in gehonnim, those worst sinners are made to emerge for judgement, found guilty and sent back to the lowest level of gehonnim (see Rashi on Ps9:18) for eternal torture. Others yet, opine that they are immediately destroyed following their bodily death. These conjectures are defective from the point of view of divine justice for neither one can argue that a "1 year" sentence is enough in all cases, neither is it fair to simply destroy a soul that has effectively been cleansed from its sins.  

We thus see that in the Quran, every soul is entitled to divine justice and mercy. Once the sinner's soul is purged and cleansed, and the balance of justice equalized in relation to the far reaching consequences of a wordly crime, then it is reunited with the Creator so as to experience divine mercy. Nobody gets an escape card through "annihilation", a proposition that only appeals to the wicked, sinful person who is comforted in his moral depravity and crimes, knowing that he can evade both the justice of this world and the next. Further, none is excluded from perfect accountability and ultimate mercy and no victim is left with the thought that its abuser will be "erased" without a just requital. The Quran in fact, complete and thorough as it always is in its argumentation, denies through a vivid scene and with added sarcasm, the desperate plea of the sinners to be annihilated so as to escape their just requital 

25:11-14"But they have denied the Hour, and We have prepared for those who deny the Hour a Blaze. When the Hellfire sees them from a distant place, they will hear its fury and roaring. And when they are thrown into a narrow place therein bound in chains, they will cry out thereupon for destruction. [They will be told], "Do not cry this Day for one destruction but cry for much destruction".

As to the Judeo-Christian tradition, their confusion and resulting philosophies, conjectures on the issue of the afterlife are due to the near complete erasure of this central issue from their scriptures. Their thinkers were then left to come up with all kinds of theories to fill the uncomfortable void. Other cultures like them all over the world, including the Greeks, came up with different scenarios more or less resembling the Islamic afterlife, using reasoning and deductions so as to make sense of how to account for the level of morality of a mortal creature. These scenarios however, like those advocated by various thought systems around the world, remain defective, incomplete in one way or another as they are the result of human conjecture upon the unseen.

The Quran makes a powerful observation revealing why the Israelites neglected that aspect of the religion until its near disappearance from their writings. They are, from all people, the most attached to this very life 

2:96"And you will most certainly find them the greediest of men for life (greedier) than even those who are polytheists; every one of them loves that he should be granted a life of a thousand years, and his being granted a long life will in no way remove him further off from the chastisement, and Allah sees what they do". 

Interestingly the verse uses "hayatin", denoting that no matter in what shape or condition that eternal earthly life is, they will take it in preference to the Hereafter. How can scriptures that speaks of God, divine laws, intelligent design, angels, prophets, moral accountability, have no explicit and repeated, stressed and emphasized mention of the afterlife? The only place where individual justice can be fulfilled to perfection? The only explanation is that they have blotted out a concept they deeply loathed due to their attachment to this life and unwillingness to face the consequences of their spiritual condition, their failures as a community bound by a collective covenant 2:93-5. Their history of internal dispute as regards even the concept of resurrection, let alone the mass of speculation on the most convenient or acceptable picture of the hereafter testify to this reality. Even more corroborative of this Quranic charge against them, is that over and over again, the Hebrew Bible promises as the climax of physical and spiritual bliss, the ushering in this very world of the messianic era, with the dead actually coming back to this world in order to be rewarded. Even prior to the ushering of that era, over and over, divine promises of material gains and rewards of all types are promised in return for spiritual uprightness Deut11. The Quran on the other hand absolves the previous prophets from such an important omission, saying they, from Abraham to Moses believed and spoke of the resurrection, judgement and life in the hereafter 2:260,7:155-6,20:48-9,40:38-9. What is also very interesting is that almost all the cataclysmic descriptions preceding the establishment of the blissful "new earth", agree with the Quran's depiction of upheaval and destruction of the universe and the earth, followed by the resurrection of the earth and all humans for judgement. This is rooted in the principle that 

28:88"all things are perishing save His Face".

 Then comes the righteous people's admission into Heaven, a place beyond the limits of the material world

 3:133"And hasten to forgiveness from your Lord; and a Garden, the extensiveness of which is (as) the heavens and the earth, it is prepared for those who guard (against evil)".

 The difference, again, is that the Bible writers place these events as happening in this world, with the Jewish people and the land of Israel being the focal point. The punishment through fire, humiliation and torture will be the lot of Israel's enemies only until the Jewish people are re-established to their station of honour among the nations Zech14:10,etc.

This peculiarity of their religion makes them focused on the here and now. Punishments and success, must be averted or sought right now. This fact, coupled with centuries of destruction and humiliation that took them many times to the brink of extinction, is what created a very special trait everyone today can see in the Jewish people. They are animated by a driving force, a determination for success so as to guarantee their self preservation, enhance their survival as a community first and foremost. They are disproportionately found in medicine, politics, finance, technology, capital control, banking, politics, lobbying, among many strategic fields. In the process of acquiring, maintaining, increasing their benefits, morality has taken a backseat. That is why Jews are disproportionately found in the most morally deprived subgroups of each aforementioned fields. That is not to say that other people and communities do not strive for success, sometimes also losing their morality in the process, but what is undeniable is that none has been so persistent on that path for so long and in such a self serving way, helping one another rise into prominent decision making positions. This is the result of their materialistic, worldly mindset coupled with collective trauma. Anyone threatening their hard earned status or possessions is faced with a disproportionate response.

There is a reason why the Quran, in its opening verses of sura baqara states that those who shall gain and find guidance from its contents are those, among other things, who are strongly and firmly convicted of the hereafter, a topic delved into at length. 

As the Quran states when referring to their baseless conjectures relating to the hereafter

 3:24"they say: The fire shall not touch us but for a few days; and what they have forged deceives them in the matter of their religion"

 and it elsewhere negates the idea that some people will never resurrect as mere wishful thinking 4:42.

There is a clear allusion however in the Tanakh, speaking of the day of resurrection the prophet Daniel says 

Dan12:2"And many who sleep in the dust of the earth will awaken-these for eternal life, and those for disgrace, for eternal abhorrence". 

Refusing the plain reading of the text, Talmudic scholars opine that "these" stands for 

"the ones who will wake up for eternal life"

 and 

"those" is for "the others who don't wake up". But how does eternal disgrace and abhorrence apply to a non-existant entity? Some other places allude to Hell, like Job18:5-21,33:18-24,36:16-17. According to Rashi, one of the highest rabbinic authority in scriptural interpretation, the fire by which God will punish certain people, a kind of fire that will not abate nor need to be sustained, is the fire of gehonnim, burning deep in a pit where are already gathered all the wicked nations destroyed through divine chastisement Isa66:16-24,Job20:26,Ezek26:20,31:14-16,32:18-32,Ps30:4etc.

It is also interesting to note the Jewish belief of reincarnation. That notion is categorically denied in the Quran 21:95,23:99-100. Nothing is eternal but the only independent cause- God. He creates an individual soul which enters the human body during the course of its formation. When the person dies, the soul awaits the resurrection of the person's body in the hereafter. Once that happens, the balance of justice is established to perfection by God who either forgives the minor evils done by the person then admits him to paradise, or makes the person undergo a painful cleansing process during which the damage done to his own soul is repaired, the balance of justice restored, and he is eventually admitted to paradise. Simple common sense and the notion of justice denies reincarnation; for which life does a reincarnated soul get rewarded/punished, is a single life enough to complete the reward/punishement resulting from the previous one? If not, how many past lives can one currently be in the process of being accounted for? how many earthly lives are enough to certain heinuous crimes of a previous life and what type of earthly punishment is appropriate? who executes it and is he/she accountable for it? what happens if all life goes extinct as already occurred during the course of earth's history? how does a vicious soul finish its cleansing process through reincarnations, how is the equilibrium of justice restored? How can this equilibrium be even possible in this world where nobody can dare claim to live a flawlessly just and good life? This means reincarnating is an infinite process in a finite universe. Also Which superior power bends the laws of causality so as to either punish/reward the reincarnated soul. Further, how does that fit with the concept of freewill and moral accountability which reincarnation is precisely supposed to answer? If someone has to experience evil due to past sins, does it mean that another individual is forced to commit evil upon that person? Who controls causality so as to make that happen? 

Reincarnation isnt found anywhere in the Tanakh nor even the Talmud/Oral Torah but in the mystical, ambiguous and multifaceted book of the Zohar (equally considered revealed by God to Moses) in order to explain evil and apparent inequalities in this life.

Sheol by the way refers to the grave, is used many times in the Tanakh. (Hell in the NT Matt5:29,30:28,Lk16:19-31,Rev20:10)

Thursday, October 29, 2026

How is a prophet recognized?

 In the Quran, through the story of ancient nations and prophets, it establishes a pattern by which to determine the truthfulness of one claiming prophethood. It then places Muhammad inside that pattern; uprightness in character which includes an unflinching, uncompromising stance as regards his mission, to have been foretold by previous prophets, having access to special knowledge, and prophecies coming true. This includes warnings of punishment for fighting and opposing the messengers. 

God does not destroy a people among whom are messengers, believers, and potential repentent sinners. An overarching theme in the Quran is that God, being the most forgiving and merciful, always grants the prophet's addressees a time of respite during which they are intensely admonished, shown signs pointing to the truth of the revelation, inflicted with corrective punishments to cause reform. The means by which such punishment is delivered may be different. The traditions speak of a scourge of famine in Mecca, and the Quran alludes to that episode. But the essential means by which the corrective punishment would be delivered with the prophet Muhammad, as already alluded to in the Meccan phase of revelation 37:171-182, was through the believers themselves. They were the main rod of God’s corrective punishment during that time of respite. The Ishmaelites believers, like the Israelites before them who were divinely commanded to engage sinful people militarily, were being established as a nation under God, charged with carrying the light of truth to the nations of the world. It is thus expected that they would be put to the ultimate test of faithfulness, demonstrating that the possibility of physical sacrifice and martyrdom for the sake of truth would not deter them from fulfilling their obligations, their covenant with God.


 And effectively by the end of the prophet's life almost the entire people he had reached with his message, who heard the admonishments, saw the signs, who were chastised with awakening punishments at the battlefield, had accepted Islam. The threatened punishement of complete destruction was thus eventually averted, as had happened with the people of Jonas/Yunus. The Quran alludes to the story of the prophet Yunus in between threats of divine destruction, so as to make the prophets Muhammad's addressees understand that the promised doom may be averted at anytime 10:95-104.

It is important to keep in mind, the Quran establishes the pattern of the prophets while the believers are in a state of weakness, even augmenting its rethoric, further antagonizing the disbelievers. As expected the people then oppose the message and prevent the people from it and get punished by the sword. End of the matter. None after him came with any of the following and was able to back his claims up:

1) comes from a common background of his addressees, meaning they know him very well, yet claims to be a Messenger, in fact the Final Messenger of God

2) warns his people of Divine chastisement

3) the chastisement comes home to roost and the partisans of the Prophet are established in the land

This is the exact process that occurred with the Bani Israil in the time of Moses, with the drowning of the host of Pharaoh and the deliverance of the Israelites, with the uprooting of the Canaanites and the establishment of the way of God. Not to mention, the Quranic invitation to the Arabs to see or recall for themselves the fate of the deniers of Nuh, Lut, Saleh, Shuayb, Hud... It is a Book of Warning that has already delivered its judgment in this world
53:36"This is a warner of the warners of old" 54:42-5"Are the unbelievers of yours better than these, or is there an exemption for you in the scriptures?...Soon shall the hosts be routed, and they shall turn (their) backs".
As said in Deuteronomy regarding the awaited prophet
"If any man will not listen to my words which he speaks in my name, I myself will make him answer for it".
God Almighty says that Prophethood has ended with the Prophet Muhammad. The Prophet bore witness to the unity of God, and his deniers were punished in this life. For those who claimed to be Prophets after him did they remain unvanquished as per the tradition of Allah, did they emerge as triumphant leaders or does their life and death fail to bear witness to their claims?

For example Musaylima emerged shortly after the Prophet's death and was killed under the orders of Abu Bakr. Before him and contemporaneous to the prophet was Saf Ibn Sayyad. He would eventually be completely discredited and in fact convert to Islam. I will speak of him in more details in another video.

Another one was Bahaullah - though later his followers branched off into the Bahai faith which is based on the nice concept of unity of religions- he died a prisoner of the Ottoman Empire. There is also Mirza Ghulam Ahmad from Qadian, Punjab - his death is widely cited to be from either one of these diseases - cholera, diarrhoea, plague, or dysentery. Besides numerous prophecies regarding the timing and manner of his death were left unfulfilled - though Ahmadis now interpret those in a metaphorical manner- but the manner of death is hardly inspiring for one claiming to be a Prophet.

There is then Rashad Khalifa who was a modern claimant based on his theory of the number 19's pattern in the Quran. Well, besides being accused of paedophilia, he was assassinated and his theories entirely discredited.

But above all, their theories did not prevail and either remained confined to a small number of followers or were simply lost and forgotten shortly after their death.

Another modern claimant was Joseph Smith in the US who started the Latter Day Saints movement and is the founder of Mormonism. He too was unfortunately assassinated. As a side note even the Mormon story has more grounds to stand on from the point of view of authenticity, than the NT story, in that there are actually known then-living individuals who executed an affidavit saying that they had, themselves, seen something of the Mormon story whereas the NT is written by anonymous people with no first hand information decades after the alleged, unsubstantiated life of the NT Jesus.

Of all the new religions that have sprung up after Islam, one may perhaps say Sikhism is also there. But Guru Nanak, the founder of the Sikh faith, never claimed for himself Prophethood. Also, Sikhism emerged as a reform movement intertwined between Hinduism and Islam. The holy book Guru Granth contains quotes from Sufi saints as well.

One may also mention the case of Paul of Tarsus.

On the face of it, finality of Prophethood seems to be a tenuous claim. After all, potentially anyone can stand up and say that he is a Prophet of God - but so far all the instances in which this has happened has failed to even come close to the scale and scope of the Prophet Muhammad's mission.

Also, if we examine the entire career of these claimants - they have singularly and absolutely failed to match the life-chart of Prophet Muhammad and moreover their death poses even more questions than their life. What is even more interesting that none of them claimed to be the final Prophet, much less Jesus who predicted the coming of a powerful figure after him, the Paraclete, that shall bring justice to the world.

Friday, January 16, 2026

The Day of Resurrection and the people of Gog and Magog

Before the ushering of the Last Day, eloquently referred to as the overwhelming, all-engulfing event 88:1, mankind will be swarming like scattered moths and locusts 54:7,101:4, spread along with all living beings all throughout the heavens and the earth.

But just as the wildest and most untamed animals will crowd together compelled by the terror of that Day 81:5, all humans who ever lived (ie the ones sceptical about that gathering must not think that if the dead have vanished from among them, they have also vanished from the Almighty) will be mustered out of their graves and gathered. 

The One who gave them life originally then dispersed them, is fully aware of each and every one of them 19:94-5,27:87,29:22,42:29,77:38. 

As a demonstration of God's limitless ability to keep track of every created entity, all living organisms besides mankind, from the smallest to the biggest, of the heavens and the earth, will be present at this gathering as well 6:38. Instinctively, every human being, past and present will recognize the gathering sound of the One commanding the universe, and will be united 

30:25,67:24,81:7,54:8"Hastening to the inviter". 

This unification was pictured on a smaller scale in this very world to Abraham's eyes 2:260. The souls will be united, from the first up to the last one that roamed this Earth 18:47, on a single day 56:49-50, including the most ungodly and uncivilized people who will have no choice but to irresistibly answer the call of the Creator, 

"seized from a near place" 

meaning they will have no way to escape or place to hide where they will be out of reach 34:51. The single, piercing and deafening cry of the summoning entity 79:13,80:33 will be so clearly perceived 20:108 wherever they will be that it will be as if one is called "from a near place". None will resist the urge to rise and gather along with the rest of mankind to render account 50:41-2, hastening like competitors in a race trying to reach the goal signs 70:43. It is to be noted that the Arabic qabr/grave often understood as the underground laying place of the dead has a broader meaning to include any location that covers the dead corpse from sight.

As a morally accountable creature, the jinn too will be gathered for judgement 6:128-130,55:39 and none of them, humans and jinn, will find a place or corner in this universe to escape God's grasp when the day of gathering is sounded 55:31-5. 

This forceful gathering, the "kneeling" of every nation 45:28, is particularly pictured through the story of Gog and Magog. 

They were an ungodly people who terrorized those weaker than them and the pious King Dhul Qarnayn managed to contain them behind a fortified wall. 

Given the urgency of the situation, the noble king used the most relevant, abundant and readily available materials at hand, as implied by the command to bring iron in pieces/lumps or blocks. It is known that iron and copper can be relatively easily extracted, as was done by ancient people that gathered these metallic minerals by simply picking up copper chunks lying around, iron hematites found in rocks and soils, or iron nodules which were collected from the bottom of swamps. That particular population encountered had already smelted iron in abundance, facilitating its use in terms of time and energy requirements for Dhul Qarnayn's project. The first step consisted in gathering the iron available at the construction site. The quantity was such that it could be levelled between the 2 cliffs. 

As a side note, from a geological viewpoint, a tight pass of even a few meters width, with high cliffs on both sides is a common formation found all over the world and more particularly in the treacherous mountainous areas of Central Asia. The iron could then have been melted or heated close to melting point in the blast furnace referred to implicitly in the passage, in order to use it within the structure of the wall, together with copper. The Quran does not give a precise description of the wall's shape and composition and list of materials used to build it, as well as of the method of execution, but does however emphasize its fortified aspect, with iron and copper, making it impenetrable by the invaders for a decreed time. How exactly were these materials used within the wall's structure is not detailed but it can be inferred that they were integrated in its construction so as to strengthen it. This could have been done by alternating within the wall with successive layers of stone, iron, copper or iron-copper alloy. The word r-d-m used by Dhul Qarnayn in reference to the requested defensive wall implies a blocking structure that is made by piling it up. The layering could also have been done by successively pouring the molten metals either by first combining them as an alloy or each on their own, inside an appropriate mould(s) placed in the desired location between the cliffs, so as to ultimately form a sort of giant sealed metal door. The process would have been done in sections by pouring molten copper on individual iron blocks that were previously flux treated, resulting in a fully metallic structure, or in combination with other materials such as stone as suggested earlier, but not in layers rather by interlocking copper coated iron blocks and stone blocks. As a side note, fluxing is a cleaning technique known for long and still applied today, to prevent oxidation and promote adhesion of 2 metals. Then again, it is not a given that the absence of a flux would necessarily prevent adhesion, even in the presence of rust, but it would certainly however accelerate corrosion. Since the king could not maintain an army there, he had to improvise using materials that could not be breached in the short to medium term (even though in the long run the structure is bound to crumble as stated by the king) hence the emphasis on the fact that despite their assaults, the invaders could not make a hole in it. This also implies that previously tried methods by this local population, using other materials did not work and the attackers could always pierce their way through. 

Another possibility which also fits the chronological description of the process is that iron pieces were placed inside a mould which was then entirely lit on fire in order to make it reach a temperature high enough for molten copper to be poured on top, allowing it to run through and fill in all the space between the iron pieces, after which the mould is removed, revealing a solid block of intermingled iron pieces and copper.

In any case these potential structures pale from the viewpoint of complexity and difficulty of execution compared to other famous ancient buildings. Again, and as stated in the verse, the protection was not meant to physically last forever but provide fast and efficient relief to his subjects, using the materials at hand.

Rulers of all times built barriers and still do today, to protect their people from outside enemies and invasions. The pious king Dhul Qarnayn was no exception and as a sign of his noble character, he regarded it as an unconditional duty of his to protect his subjects 

18:94-7"Shall we then pay you a tribute on condition that you should raise a barrier between us and them? He said: That in which my Lord has established me is better, therefore you only help me with workers, I will make a fortified barrier between you and them". 

After having successfuly done so, instead of pronouncing his own greatness as Kings normally do, this Noble and Pious King tells the people that all things will eventually crumble when their appointed time comes, as stated in the sura's beginning as well as often repeated elsewhere in the Quran, including his own monumental achievements which are in fact not really his, but the result of God's mercy upon him

 18:98"He said: This is a mercy from my Lord, but when the promise of my Lord comes to pass He will make it level with the ground". 

The whole sura concludes with a reminder of such principle which must be impressed in the mind of the God-conscious 

"they whose labor is lost in this world's life and they think that they are well versed in skill of the work of hands. These are they who disbelieve in the communications of their Lord and His meeting, so their deeds become null". 

All things, even the most monumental constructions are eventually reduced to dust and levelled with the ground as stated by Dhul Qarnayn in the verses. Other righteous men such as the prophet Hud equally warned their nations against their materialistic world view and the perception that their worldly achievements will last forever 26:124-9. This is one of the purest and most essential monotheistic principle, nothing exists by its own capacity except for God's everlasting Glorious Self 

55:26-7,28:88"All things are perishing but His Face". 

Not finding any trace of that wall today or its definite location thus agrees with Dhul Qarnayn's statement concerning its inevitable end. Also, assuming it isnt mentioned in present day available historical records how does that preclude it has once existed before it got levelled with the ground as stated by Dhul Qarnayn? Is every construction in the history of mankind regardless of its size known, written in records or memorized throughout time and never forgotten? 

The more profound message is that escaping that rampart, something that is bound to happen as per Dhul Qarnayn's words given the temporary nature of the structure, does not mean that one can ultimately escape God's justice 

18:99"And We will leave some of them on that day surge against others (like waves); and the trumpet will be blown, so We will gather them in gathering". 

It is to be noted, the verse only starts speaking of the day of judgement after the reference to the trumpet blow and the gathering of all humanity. At that same time that the towns who otherwise would never return, will be brought back from their death to answer to the call, the Gog and Magog will also be raised and let loose to descend from every elevation since all these natural places of refuge once particularly used by these plunderers will be destroyed

 20:105-7,21:95-7"And it is binding on a town which We destroy that they shall not return. Until when Gog and Magog are let loose and they shall descend from every elevated place. And the true promise shall draw nigh, then lo! the eyes of those who disbelieved shall be fixedly open: O woe to us! surely we were in a state of heedlessness as to this; nay, we were unjust". 

Nothing is said here about the necessity for a wall to be destroyed for the Gog and Magog to come out since it obviously is talking of judgement day and their forceful gathering with all humanity, Ie the previously destroyed towns have now returned, and they are descending from every elevation, not through an opening in a wall or from a specific location but from all directions. In other words, there are 2 occasions where the Gog and Magog will come forth; 

- Following the destruction of the wall that contained them

- On the day of judgement together with all of humanity, this includes the actual barbaric population encountered by Dhul Qarnayn, those that surged after the wall collapsed, as well as their descendants, all resurrected and irresistibly gathering. If one were to say that the barrier had been broken or damaged long ago, as reflected in some narrations, and they swarmed the Earth and attacked the people, then this claim would still not contradict the Quran. It is not necessary that they attacked immediately after their barrier broke but took a few hundred years to do so and they may attack in stages as well, with their final onslaught still to come. The Quran does not indicate toward the timings of these events but informs us of what they would do. This is corroborated not only from the Quran but also the reported sayings of the prophet. For example in one instance it says that following the surging of the Gog and Magog, pilgrimage to Kaaba will not be discontinued until the day of resurrection. It also says that the pious Arabs will remain unharmed until evil and sin becomes widespread and only then people of Gog and Magog will begin attacking them.

The mention of Gog and Magog and the towns in the context of resurrection and judgement clearly is meant at picturing the fact that people will be brought back to God from wherever they might be, whether they lead a sedentary or nomadic and untamed lifestyle. As a side note, after the Gog and Magog's coming forth, the "drawing nigh" of God's promise made to the disbelievers spoken of in 21:97 is in reference to the now inevitable prospect of punishment they were promised in this world and to which they were heedless, their soon hurling in hell spoken of in the following verse after their judgement 21:98, as they look on with terror inside the now opened gates of hellfire that is brought near to those concerned 18:100,26:91,79:36. Further, in Classical Arabic and the Semitic languages in general, it is common to call multiple tribes by the names of their ancestors. Plenty examples can be given from the HB. That is why, as a side note, we see Rabbinical writings and the NT depicting Gog and Magog as 2 distinct nations although earlier the Tanakh in Gen10 only refers to Magog as a people descending from Noah's son Japheth, and later Ezekiel38 speaks of Gog as a ruler of several territories or people, including Magog, meaning he was either a foreigner to Magog and had his own nation that later became known by his name or he was from Magog itself and some of the people he ruled over besides those of Magog became known by the name of their ruler, hence the later references to Gog and Magog as 2 nations Rev20.

Monday, October 6, 2025

Solomon, the honorable prophet

From his father the prophet-King David, Solomon had inherited a material kingdom. As reflected in this introduction to a prayer he made in front of his people, once he inherited the kingdom of his father 

27:15-16"And We had certainly given to David and Solomon knowledge, and they said, "Praise [is due] to Allah, who has favored us over many of His believing servants. And Solomon inherited David. He said, "O people, we have been taught the language of birds, and we have been given from all things. Indeed, this is evident bounty". 

There is here a clear distinction between the special knowledge both David and Solomon received from God, and the inheritance. 

Neither is righteousness something that can be inherited. Spiritual eminence is not something that can be passed on to one's children by virtue of biological descendancy. One's spirituality is nurtured and increased through one's own efforts, reasonable observation of the signs which the Quran says surround us at all moments, including in our inner selves, as well as reflecting on the guidance sent to mankind through the prophets. 

Since Solomon had reached spiritual uprightness in this manner, in addition was equally chosen and elevated to the status of prophethood, just as his father David was, he might have assumed that the same would eventually be the case of his own child, regardless of his current condition. That hope, which is but natural for a parent, was however put to rest at the sight of a jasad on his throne. 

The Arabic means a body. This body can be animate or inanimate, that of a human, an angel, a jinn or even an animal. To pinpoint which one is meant, it suffices to read and ponder upon the rest of this highly eloquent passage. 

Upon seeing that jasad/body on his throne, the prophet Solomon made 2 prayers. First asking for ghafr/God's covering. This is the covering of protection towards any potential shortcomings. No sin is ascribed to Solomon in the passage. A pious person often makes such a prayer when upset by the sight of evil, which was the case here, as will be shown later. 

Second, Solomon prayed that his kingdom dissolves at his death, without it passing on to anyone after him 

38:34-5"And certainly We tried Sulaiman, and We put on his throne a (mere) body, so he turned (to Allah). He said, "My Lord, protect me and grant me a kingdom such as will not belong to anyone after me. Indeed, You are the Bestower". 

And this is the final clue inevitably pointing to the identity of that body which Solomon saw on his throne and which prompted him to make such a prayer; it could not be anyone or anything else than his own son, otherwise the prayer to end his kingdom after him would be irrelevant. He saw the evil potential of his son. This sight shocked him, as any pious person naturally would be, hence his prayer to be protected from sin. Then, knowing what wicked rulers are capable of if given power the like he had, he did not want his kingdom to fall in the hands of his sinful and undeserving heir. 

The verse is clearly alluding to the individual sitting on the throne derogatorily, not worthy to be spoken of as a proper person and having his identity described. It is but a mere body, a piece of flesh, just as anyone devoid of spirituality, is. The Quran as well as scriptures of the past, repeatedly allude to those lacking God-consciousness as lifeless or dead, or as mere animals like the rest of worldly creatures. Because they lack the inner distinction, spirituality, that separates between humans and the rest of biological creation. None would have been admitted to sit on a king's throne other than a very close person such as one's child, more particularly the future heir, who would be designated ahead of time as was the custom. Solomon's son came to power at the death of his father and when he was 40 years old according to the HB in 1Kings14:21. Solomon had thus all the time to try and evaluate the potential of his future heir, eventually forming an opinion about him. But at some point, seeing him on the throne made him visualize the devastating effects a wicked ruler might cause, a spiritually dead person or a mere body as eloquently stated in the Quran, not worthy of being properly introduced. The HB equally states Solomon came to know of the future destruction of his kingdom. It says this was a divine decree, unrelated to his son's condition, who would nevertheless turn out to be spiritually corrupt 2Chronicles12, ie a mere body of flesh and bones, as stated in the Quran. 

The Bible further says this divine decree was aimed at punishing Solomon for his alleged participation in idolatry

 1Kings11"I will surely tear the kingdom from you, and I shall give it to your servant...from the hands of your son I shall tear it". 

The Quran, far from ascribing such enormous sins to the prophets, states that it was Solomon himself who requested for his kingdom to end after him, and this was because he became convinced of his son's unworthiness. Among the hardest trials of life is seeing one's own children and other family members hopelessly going astray. But Solomon, known for his wisdom understood the inevitable, and at that point dissociated himself from his wicked son who was bound to be the future ruler. How could anyone, let alone a prophet of Solomon's caliber, willing to go to such extent so as to safeguard his integrity and piety, be accused of idolatry? Even the prophet Nuh could not control his fatherly bond when confronted to his sinful son. He insisted on asking for God's mercy for his disbelieving son, although God had warned him not to be involved with the sinners no matter who they are once the punishment is unleashed 

11:36-47"And Noah called to his Lord and said, "My Lord, indeed my son is of my family; and indeed, Your promise is true; and You are the most just of judges! He said, "O Noah, indeed he is not of your family; indeed, he is [one whose] work was other than righteous, so ask Me not for that about which you have no knowledge. Indeed, I advise you, lest you be among the ignorant. [Noah] said, "My Lord, I seek refuge in You from asking that of which I have no knowledge. And unless You forgive me and have mercy upon me, I will be among the losers". 

Nuh was rebuked by God for his plea. Solomon however, as already pointed, did not persist and understood, through his wisdom that he should separate himself from the disbelievers, be it his own progeny. 

Stripped from its divine protection, the kingdom thus rapidly disintegrated following Solomon's death, as reflected in the HB. Again in the Quran, this is not a punishment for Solomon's sins as the lying pens of Israel would have the gullible believing, those unaware of these scribes' consistent habit to blame in their writings, their miseries on the supposed sins of their prophets. 

It all started with a prayer from Solomon to have his kingdom dissolved after his death. In addition to granting him his prayer, Solomon was honoured with increases in his kingdom that could not be passed on in anyway, contrary to the material kingdom that could not be made to disappear overnight after his death, and that had to be temporarily inherited by his wicked son. Solomon received first and foremost spiritual increase through his being made near to God 38:36-40, and was granted intangible power, the dominion over certain natural elements and worldly creatures including the jinn, and certain animals of whom only he understood the saying 27:18. 

In that verse, the Arabic QAWL, which describes the communication of the ants among eachother, is derived from the root Qaf-W-L and it means communicating in any way possible and not necessarily through soundwaves. Effectively, it doesnt say that Solomon's reaction to the ants' communication was due to his hearing them and neither does he talk back to them. Solomon was granted the ability to detect and understand their type of communication, which consists of chemical signals. In constrast, we see further in that passage the prophet Solomon talking back to the hoophoe, the messenger bird, using clear speech. This is because both Solomon and the bird could communicate through soundwaves. The Quran doesnt attach any of the mystical and supernatural powers ancient peoples attributed to the hoophoe. He has no capacities whatsoever beyond what can be observed of him in its natural environment. Instead Solomon is the one given the supernatural ability to understand his thoughts and communications, nobody else directly. From a scientific viewpoint, it isnt beyond reason to imagine humans and animals verbally communicating and understanding one another, even on an intricate level. Solomon was given mastery over the seen and unseen creatures on a level no human was granted before and after him. Through that encounter, Solomon, who was not an idolater as is depicted in the HB, is increased in his spiritual awareness and gratefulness to God. This pattern is seen in all of his favours, showing Solomon's constant return to Allah whenever he notices the extent of his dominion. 

The ants are describes as having recognized Solomon during his travel. It is interesting to note that sometimes a single ant colony can stretch for kilometres, with information passing all throughout it. Meaning a group of ants can be aware of information connected to a distant location. They are also known to possess a level of collective intelligence allowing them to perform complex tasks requiring the participation of individuals spread throughout the colony, without each of those individuals being shown or explained the problem to resolve. 

Although, as already shown, the verse does not state that the saying of the ant was in the form of human speech, rather that it was Solomon who was able to understand them, some critics among Christians and Jews have denigrated this miracle, forgetting what their own scriptures say about God giving even to animals, such as a donkey, the ability to utter a clear speech Numb22:21-30. That is besides the talking serpent in the creation account which is one of the reasons leading certain embarrassed Christians and Jews to see the whole story as an allegory, although nothing in it hints at the author intending to write a fiction.

That ability of the prophet Solomon, although absent from the Torah, transpires in the rabbis' understanding of 1Kings3:15, deriving from the Talmud that upon Solomon's awakening from a sleep during which he received revelation, he was granted, along with riches, honour, wisdom, the ability to understand the language of animals so much so that 

"He would hear a bird chirp and understand its language, a dog would bark and he would understand its language".

This kind of supernatural dominion over all kinds of creatures of the earth is a great favour from God and also a tremendous test. That authority was divinely granted even to non-believing people, such as the powerful Babylonian king Nebuchadnezzar often called God's "servant" because of him being God's means by which destruction was inflicted upon His enemies Jer25:9,27:6,Dan2:38.

Among the favors bestowed on Solomon was his dominion over the unseen entities. Many superstitions were attached, and still are, with those beings, most of which the Quran directly rejects. Humans were and still are believed to be able to master them. The Quran refutes that belief, as well as all derived occult endeavor, again through the story of the prophet Solomon. 

He was given unlimited mastery over them, had the capacity to summon and use the jinn, at will, and for the accomplishement of positive actions only 27:17,38-41. This however was a favour from God and was done by God's express command. By their description, as shayateen, some of them bound in chains, others threatened in case of rebellion, it appears that these jinn were enslaved by Allah to Solomon as a means of punishment. The Quran distinguishes in other places between them, the righteous and the sinners. Their subjection, was thus not of Solomon's own will or power and the jinns concerned had no say in the matter or else they would face God's chastisement. They were under God's complete control in the process 21:81-2 meaning Solomon by himself had absolutely no special ability that allowed him the possibility to master them the way he did, use them at will and without any fear of having to render an account 34:12,38:36-38. The jinn as depicted in the Quranic version of their interaction with Solomon, cannot escape their state of utter subjection. And this situation, again, was unrelated to Solomon's will and power, for even after his passing, their condition did not change.  

As the Quran states in the context of Solomon's death 
34:14"the jinn came to know plainly that if they had known the unseen, they would not have tarried in abasing torment". 
The passage refers to Solomon who passed away but whose dead body was held in place by a wooden staff for a while until it disintegrated, eaten by a woodworm. It is only when his inanimate body fell to the ground that the jinn, living under his servitude, realized he was dead. The passage not only shows them as subservient to one of Allah's servants, but they are unable to even fathom something superficially hidden from them, yet very close: how then can they gratify people’s appeals to learn the secrets of the unseen? When speaking of Iblis himself, the Quran says that his pledge to God that he would doubtlessly lead astray a portion of Adam's descendants, was in fact a conjecture and guess. The archetype of jinn has no access to special knowledge, not even of the future. It was just a coincidence that his conjecture and guess became true 
34:20"And certainly Iblis found true his conjecture concerning them, so they followed him, except a party of the believers".

Jewish oral tradition however, it was through magic, knowledge of the occult and deception that Solomon, through his own will and power, was able to subject them. Until he was overpowered by one of those demons, Ashmadai who chased him from his throne. 

That such an eminent personality, favoured by God and drawn near to Him, a prophet imparted knowledge of the unseen like all prophets, was not able to control the jinn except by God's will is an emphatic rejection of the claim that some random people with alleged powers have the capacity to summon them at will, and make them perform certain tasks, most of the time for evil purposes, or obtain hidden knowledge, another belief concerning the jinn rejected by the Quran 34:14. 

On a more specific note, it also negates the notion that Solomon himself, contrary to the suspicions and calumnies of some of his contemporaries and the subsequent generations, used to practice the occult sciences

 2:102"And they followed what the Shaitans chanted of sorcery in the reign of Sulaiman, and Sulaiman was not an unbeliever, but the Shaitans disbelieved".

We see traces of these allegations even in the Jewish historian Josephus' works. He relates how Solomon had, through incantations and the use of the occult sciences, mastery of demons, could perform exorcisms. He speaks of a Jew contemporary to him that made use of these Solomonic practices. Obviously the people misinterpreted Sulayman's ability, granted to him by God, of controlling entities of the unseen for his own benefit. Such falsehood is found in a wide variety of Solomonic lore, including the 5th century CE Testament of Solomon, each drawing from oneanother as well as other lost sources, written and oral. Particularly among Greek Christians that used amulets, medallions seals or rings with his name. What we find in certain Jewish traditions in regards his perception of the language and behaviour of birds, is that his ability wasnt a divine gift but due to his mastery of ornithomancy, an occult science involving birds (Pesika de-Rav Kahana, Ecclesiastes Rabbah). Here again, just as it does with his other supernatural abilities where it clearly states they were divinely granted gifts to him, and that Solomon was humbly grateful to his Lord, the Quran introduces the story of Solomon's interraction with the bird messenger with a prayer 

27:19"My Lord, grant me that I should be grateful for Your favour that You bestowed on me and on my parents, and that I should do good such as You would be pleased with, and make me enter, by Your mercy, into Your servants, the good ones".

We thus find from the Dead Sea Scrolls, to the Testament of Solomon, that there were traditions associating Solomon with the supernatural, all of them mixing truth and falsehood, sometimes in the process smearing his character, will and intentions. The commentary on Ecclesiastes 2:8 in the Talmud (Gittin 68a-b) is not the origin of the connection between Solomon and demons in Jewish tradition. This commentary is a harmonization of several older traditions which the writers retrofitted into Ecclesiastes. These traditions, besides the ones referred to earlier, find their source all the way back to the Babylonian captivity, as seen from the cultural influences. This is where, as affirmed in the Quran 2:102, the association of Solomon to occult endeavors started, just as was done to the angelic messengers Harut and Marut. The verse says that it was rather the Jews of the time themselves who, while being aware of the warnings, eagerly desired this knowledge, and for the attainment of evil objectives. Here the Quran exposes them, as is clear from the pattern in their books and traditions, for transposing their own sins and evil desires unto their leaders and prophets.

The canonized Jewish scriptures themselves do not spare Solomon, depicting him as an idolater, hoarding riches from oppressed nations, horses and women. This is where the Quran acts as the muhaymin/the guardian and arbiter of previous scriptures and traditions, filtering truth from falsehood, as shown earlier in regards to Solomon's supernatural capacities and his monotheism, his gratefulness, wisdom when utlising his worldly gifts, as well as even gentleness, God consciousness with the opposite gender.

When he heard of the Queen of Sheba, the extent of her wealth and her false religion, Solomon sent her a letter of invitation to submit to the unique Creator. The queen firstly declined her officials' desire to answer Solomon's invitation militarly because she regarded the use of force as was done throughout history by imperialist rulers seeking to subdue another population a human and spiritual disaster. In fact it is a trend seen in the history of the prophets that they always opposed and denounced tyrannical regimes and oppressors. The first stage of their mission always comprised a very stern, firm and unequivocal opposition against the leaders in a nation, largely responsible for the moral degradation of the masses who are in turn guilty of holding them in high esteem. 

So this noble Queen, instead of doing as her advisors suggested and go to war, decides to first test Solomon's intentions, in relation to his letter written in Allah's name and calling for her to submit to Allah. It was not a threatening letter, but rather one filled with a noble speech/karim 
27:29"surely a honourable letter has been delivered to me". 
She did not immediately ask more specificities as to his religious call because she first wanted to ascertain the purity of Solomon's inner self. This is a crucial lesson, one often repeated in the Quran and neglected, corrupted in the previous scriptures; the unflinching moral uprightness of a prophet of God can never be compromised so long as he is representing the divine will among a people. The Quran places this trait as one of the most recognizable condition for the truthfulness of an envoy from God. This reality is expected, contrary to the depictions made in the previous scriptures, that someone sent by, and representing the ultimate truth, should be the best embodiment of that truth among his addressees. This logic did not escape even the pagan queen, who sent Solomon expensive gifts instead of declaring war as desired by her counselors, or asking outright the nature of the message he was calling her to. She wanted to see what his reaction would be, whether he would be interested in power and riches rather than spiritual matters as he was suggesting in his letter. Was he actually telling her to submit to God for her own good or because he wanted to benefit from her conversion in some way. It is interesting to note here that long before, Solomon's father David had foreseen and prayed for the neighboring kingdoms to seek peace and be gentle to his son 
Ps72:10"may the kings of Sheba and Seba approach with a gift". 
Solomon however promptly returned the gifts. Wisdom and prophethood to him were the best gifts a human could hope for. The Quran points to that reality in relation to the prophet Muhammad. The wealthy rejected him among other reasons, because of him lacking in worldly eminence 
43:32"and the mercy of your Lord is better than what they amass". 
This is in stark contrast with the Biblical narrative, according to which the king Solomon, depicted as hoarding wealth from his subjects, enslaved nations and neighboring kingdoms, readily accepted the gifts of the queen 
1Kings10:10-15"one hundred and twenty talents of gold and very many spices and precious stones; there had never arrived such an abundance of spices as those which the Queen of Sheba gave to king Solomon. Also Hiram's ships that delivered gold from Ophir, brought from Ophir a huge quantity of almog-wood and precious stones..The weight of gold which came to Solomon in one year was 666 talents of gold. Aside from [that which came through] merchants and the commerce of spice-peddlers and all the dependent kings and the regents of the land". 
The righteous prophets of God, contrary to that corrupted depiction that is made, never compromised their integrity with worldly riches. No matter the aspects in which God raised them above their contemporaries, they never used their spiritual gifts in exchange of material reward. When the prophets Joseph and Daniel attracted the leaders of their time's attention through their spiritual gifts, they used this attention to be placed in eminent social positions so as to benefit mankind Gen41,Dan2,5:17,29,6:1-4.

Solomon was no exception to that rule and upon returning the queen's gifts, he communicated God's decree that
 27:37"we will most certainly come to them with hosts which they shall have no power to oppose, and we will most certainly expel them therefrom in abasement, and they shall be in a state of ignominy". 
Solomon not only rejected the offer brought by the queen's envoys, but did so in a forceful way so as to leave no ambiguity as to his intentions. Not only was he one who could not be bribed with money, but his message of spiritual reform is certainly not one that can be bought. This proved how upright Solomon was as a person and how convinced he was of the truth he was communicating. The Queen of Sheba already inclined to righteousness and was actually reassured by Solomon's gesture of refusing material offers, even ready to go to war so as to not compromise his message. Solomon's threat of invasion was crucial in conveying these points. She didnt take offense at his reaction because she hoped that he would be serious in his intent 
27:35"The queen said, when the kings enter a land, they ruin it and debase its honourable people. They do just the same. I shall send them a gift, and wait to see with what reply my envoys return". 
This was the wits and wisdom of Solomon who actually did not want to put the threat of invasion into action. This is seen by the fact that immediately after the Queen's envoys were sent away with their gifts, Solomon, instead of mobilizing his army as he had threatened, requested for his assembly of jinn to perform a deed so impressive that it would expose whether
 27:42"she gets to the truth or is one of those who are not guided aright". 
He asked them to transport her throne, the symbol of a ruler's dominion, unto him in the blink of an eye. Solomon wanted to make her see beyond her and her people's materialistic mindset. They were people, as already shown, who thought that anyone or anything could be bought with riches. And the throne is the highest symbol of worldly power and riches. He wanted to make her understand the deep reality that her power isnt in her hands but could be stripped in an instant by Allah, and her dominion transferred to whomsoever Allah desires. But in the meantime that the plan was discussed and executed by Solomon, the queen left her country to meet him face to face, impressed by this wise man uninterested in worldly riches and ready to summon formidable forces to defend the dignity of the message he was calling her to. As she left, the plan was put into place and the throne was displaced in her absence, then brought to Solomon's palace where it was arranged in a manner so as to be recognizable to her when she would be called to see it. This shocked Solomon himself, who in his humble pattern as described in the Quran, immediately attributed that event to God's will and power 27:40. This is the reality of the noble, humble and pious prophet Solomon, unlike the idolatrous and ungrateful depiction that is made of him in previous scriptures 
38:30"most excellent the servant, surely he was frequent in returning to Allah"
2:102"and Solomon disbelieved not".
Neither was his father David a murderous adulterer, nor his mother an adulteress as shamelessly depicted by the lying pens of the scribes of Israel. They were praiseworthy people who were bestowed with favours by Allah, as humbly recalled in Solomon's prayer, quoted just before the story of his encounter with the Queen
 27:19"My Lord, grant me that I should be grateful for Your favour that You bestowed on me and on my parents, and that I should do good such as You would be pleased with, and make me enter, by Your mercy, into Your servants, the good ones".
But Solomon did not need to send for her to come see her throne, she had arrived in the meantime and so the throne was pointed to her. She confessed there that she had already inclined to Islam by what she saw and heard from the prophet Solomon even before seeing this miracle. After all, she did go out of her way to come and see him personally instead of confronting him militarily when he rejected her envoys with the gifts and sent with them a declaration of war. Allah further confirmed her statement by pointing that the only thing that hindered her from finding the right path prior to coming to meet Solomon was not stubbornness or willful rebellion, but her upbringing in a sinful nation 27:43. 
As she entered the splendid palace whose floors were in places made of glass, it had on her the illusory effect of a wide water expanse. The Queen thus tucked up her dress to avoid stepping on water, exposing a portion of her legs. 

The fantastic tales at that point related by some commentators of her having donkey's legs due to being a jinn hybrid from her mother's side are inauthentic reports traced to Kaab al Ahbar and Wahab ibn Munabbih. 

This tucking of her dress was a gesture beneath the dignity of a woman of her royalty. Solomon then immediately displayed another aspect of his high character. To avoid her further embarrassment  he told her the floor is made of glass. This was the last thing that opened her eyes and heart 
27:44"My Lord i have been inflicting much wrong on myself. Now I submit myself with Solomon to Allah, the Lord of the Worlds". 
In the racially prejudiced and monolatrous mindset of the scribes of the HB, this queen who had nevertheless recognized Solomon's wisdom, who had left her land, abasing herself to come and seek knowledge from another king, recognized and blessed the ethno-centric "Lord your God" and His "eternal love for Israel", but inexplicably remained a heathen 1Kings10. After all, you do not want some far away nation to come and claim their rights in the land as part of the "chosen race". The NT in Lk11 Similarly doesnt indicate whether she eventually abandoned her polytheistic ways, but hints at her being higher in righteousness than the Jewish contemporaries of Jesus. It is also interesting how in the Biblical account, she praises the tribal "Lord your God" while in the Quran she submits herself, together with Solomon, to one and the same God, Lord of all worlds. 

This is the consistent Quran pattern of exposing and correcting the manipulations of the scriptures of the past. In the Quranic account, every step in the story revolves around Solomon's wisdom and talent to reform her heart and bring her progressively to wilfully surrender herself to God. First through a letter beginning in a way unheard of for the purely materialistic conquering kings of ancient times, starting with a mention of Allah, and the well known semitic terminology "al Rahman" 27:30. The Second manner in which Solomon cleverly brought the Queen to spiritual submission, was by rejection of the gifts, proving his wisdom. This is probably one of the deepest and most significant difference between the Quran version and the incomprehensible Biblical depiction of the encounter. Here is a most wise and knowledgeable king, having such wealth that the Queen was left breathless, having access to the deep realities, but yet after his exchange in which he demonstrated his knowledge, was content in receiving all kinds of material gifts, instead of having the Queen reform herself spiritually as a result of his demonstration 1Kings10. The third device put into place to bring the Queen to submit herself to the sole Creator, was by displacing the Queen's throne between the time she had last seen it and her arrival to Solomon's palace, he demonstrated what he had previously affirmed to the queen's envoys 
27:36"what Allah has given me is better than what He has given you". 
Notice Solomon's intricate answer, besides demonstrating his wisdom in refusing the gifts, points to them that whatever riches they possess isnt from them but from Allah who gave it to them. The envoys must have reported to their queen of this other peculiarity of the king, in relation to his piety. Finally to have in his possession such an impressive structure as a floor of glass, but nevertheless remain a pious, grateful and God-conscious king was the last thing the queen needed to be convinced of the right spiritual path upon which Solomon was walking. The Quran reflects this special feature of Solomon in several places, including as he prayed Allah to make him the owner of something that can never be passed on, spiritual excellence 38:35. Eventually after her, her people became conceited and ungrateful to God's favours, which were consequently withdrawn 34:15-19.

The queen of Sheba's encounter with the prophet Solomon is a story related in many different ways in oral and textual tradition, both within and outside the current Bible canon. For example in the Babylonian Talmud (Tractate Gittin 68a-b), both the background and the details are far from the Quran version. In this Talmud version, the bird is described as having the power to cause the wilderness to bloom, thanks to a magical stone, which was sought by Solomon. He needed it to cleave blocks of rock for the building of his temple. Using his mastery of magic, Solomon tricks the demon lord Ashmadai, to give away the stone's location. No interaction between Solomon and the hoophoe is depicted at any point. We find elements of the story scattered throughout different midrash. In Jewish understanding, a midrash is a story within the Talmud, meant at explaining a Biblical passage or conveying a moral point. The story may be historical or not, partially modified or kept as received, so long as the writers' intention is correctly conveyed. We find throughout the ages rabbis and commentators disagreeing on whether a report within the Talmud should be classified as non-literal or literal. Most often that classification depends on a scholar’s bias. For instance Elijah in 2Kings2:11 is described as ascending to heaven. Commentators argue as to whether he kept his body and soul, only his soul or was separated from his body which he could then dress and undress at will. Then the Talmud describes numerous encounters of prominent Jews throughout the ages with Elijah, following his ascension. Rabbis will either consider these encounters non literal(midrash) or literal, depending on how the primary information is interpreted.

As to the current Biblical canon anyway, it is far from constituting the standard of historical accuracy. Very little in terms of authenticity, distinguishes it from what is arbitrarily deemed "apocrypha". These different Solomonic stories agree with the Quran in minor places, because there are remnants of truth common to the Quran and these traditions, whether they were canonized or deemed apocrypha by the unknown Bible compilers and editors throughout the ages. 

What is remarkable is the coherent and intricate manner in which these minor points commonly found in several channels of transmission, come together in the Quran. One would expect to find a recipe for theological, reasonable, inner textual and historical disaster as is found in the canonized text of the Bible. Yet all these points correlate not only in the story itself, but within the larger sura and the Quran overall from a theological, reasonable and inner textual standpoint. For instance the background of the story itself is something unheard of in the traditions of the past. The Quran states that the whole encounter was triggered by a bird whose tiny heart was moved at seeing the false worship of a people, then reported it to the prophet Solomon 27:20-27. The Quran in many places states that the entire creation, animate and inanimate glorifies and worships Allah in a manner humans cannot perceive. That glorification had reached particular intensity in the time of Solomon's father, the prophet David, whom most of creation would join him in his praise of Allah. This is what is meant by the Quran maintaining its consistency despite its illiterate author and stealthy, unseen assistants, selecting in a plethora of oral and written traditions, cherry picking along the way the convenient parts that agree with its most subtle meanings, without ever being noticed, then putting together this intricate discourse free from any discrepancy. 

When a tiny bird with limited mental capacities is hurt by the sight of mankind's ungratefulness towards its Creator, that even inanimate objects devoid of any mental faculties are praising God, that the most massive among them such as mountains wouldnt be able to bear the spiritual weight of a revelation the like of this Quran 59:21,13:31 then what is amiss in mankind that many are unable or unwilling to worship the One Creator? Man is blessed with the most advanced reasoning capacities in creation, combining concrete and spiritual perception 20:50,30:30,76:3,90:8-10,91:7-10. Man is ingrained at birth with a cognizance of the higher realities 23:78,46:26,67:23,76:2 aided with guidance through revelation 2:38-9,7:35-6,20:123. Why would he not, under such circumstances recognize and bow to his Creator? 

Solomon, as seen above, was aware at all times of the higher reality. And this again is depicted in the Quran through the meaningful example of his grand cavalry 38:30-3. He attributed it, and all hus favors to Allah and appreciated these gifts due to his constant remembrance of God, just like the pious King Dhul Qarnayn, and considered his faith more important than any worldly advantages 
38:30"And to David We gave, Solomon. Excellent was the servant; indeed, he was (always) returning (to Allah)". 
Contrary to the lowly depiction that is made of him by the scribes of the Bible, instead of his possessions and power leading him to excess and sin, the Quran depicts him as increasing in gratitude and never faltering from God's remembrance. Despite, or more precisely through these favours, he is instead increased in God-awareness. These noble rulers that passed away, knew very well that despite their worldly powers and grand kingdoms, a day would come when it will be manifest that the true kingdom was always and never ceased to be Allah's 40:16. Anytime he experienced God's bounties upon him, Solomon did not neglect the spiritual implications and, as is the case in 27:19 when he perceived the communications of ants beneath him, requested from Allah to be increased in spiritual awareness and gratefulness so as to never fall into complacency. Again later in 27:40 as he witnessed some of the supernatural abilities of one of the beings put at his service by God 
"this is of the grace of my Lord that He may try me whether I am grateful or am ungrateful; and whoever is grateful, verily he is grateful for his own soul, and whoever is ungrateful, then my Lord is Self-Sufficient, Bounteous". 
Every time Sulayman could have fallen into arrogance and conceit, the alarm bell of God-consciousness was there to remind him of God's favour. This awareness was both internally and outwardly expressed. Even when addressing the rulers of neighboring kingdoms, which are contexts where a king would naturally boast of his own power and prestige, Sulayman severely rebuked a Queen's emissary that humbly came to him with precious gifts
 27:36"But what Allah has given me is better than what He has given you". 
The wording itself reveals Sulayman's gratitude to God, the source of all that he, and all human beings might possess.

In 38:30-40 Solomon's spiritual awareness is again depicted. The passage begins by praising his nobility of character. It then gives 2 examples to illustrate this point: 

- his love for the worldly benefits under his possession stemmed from his constant remembrance of God 
"Verily, I have come to love the love of all that is because of/AAN my rembrence of my Sustainer". 
He always kept in mind the higher meaning of things. It is a mark of the God-conscious to remain grateful when deriving both concrete and abstract benefits from the nature upon which mankind has been assigned vicegerency 40:79-81. "Aan" is a preposition with at least 10 meanings, all of which depend on the context and the sentence. One of those meanings is to denote causality "because of" as in 9:114,11:53etc and the passage gives several examples, including that of the horses, that attest to Solomon being God-conscious in all situations as stated in the beginning. To a great commander such as Solomon, the scene of his grand cavalry must have been so spectacular, that he personally was eager to touch and sooth his horses 
"(Then he ordered:) ‘Bring them (horses) back to me’. And he began to rub (their) legs and necks".
Although the HB includes his grand cavalry among his list of failures 1Kings11:1-10,Deut17:16, besides indulging in idolatry, it does portray him with similar wisdom as the above. This is typically due to the past scriptures and traditions being amalgams of truth and falsehood. After speaking of the abundance of wealth and all kinds of possessions he had acquired and enjoyed, the prophet-king Solomon declares that despite the opulence, God-consciousness never departed from him 
Ecc2:4-9"...So I became great, and I increased more than all who were before me in Jerusalem; also my wisdom remained with me". 
- The second example used to illustrate Sulayman's lofty and pious character was, as detailed earlier, his successful passing of the test he was put through, as he saw his unworthy son's body sitting on his throne. He immediately sought God's protection from sin, then dissociated himself even from his progeny for God's sake. How could anyone willing to go to such extent to safeguard his integrity and piety, be accused of idolatry? It is with such impeccable pattern of behaviour and higher outlook of life that the prophet Solomon lived and ruled. One finds that this pattern of thinking was established in Solomon even in his youth, when he had just inherited the throne from his father David and requested from God
 1Kings3"..give to Your servant an understanding heart to judge Your people, that I may discern between good and evil..."Because you have asked this thing, and have not asked long life for yourself, nor have asked riches for yourself, nor have asked the life of your enemies, but have asked for yourself understanding to discern justice, behold, I have done according to your words; see, I have given you a wise and understanding heart, so that there has not been anyone like you before you, nor shall any like you arise after you. And I have also given you what you have not asked: both riches and honour, so that there shall not be anyone like you among the kings all your days".
His immaterial request was thus granted 38:40, and as a reward of his humility and turning-away from worldly ambition, and as part of the spiritual kingdom he was exclusively given, he was granted mastery over entities of the spiritual realm 38:36-38.

So exceedingly above the ordinary was Solomon's wisdom that it could not but have been specially given to him. We find in the Hebrew Scriptures, despite the presence of falsehood, remnants of that reality. When he received Prophetic vision during his sleep, he was asked by God what would be his wish, now that he had been made to inherit a grand kingdom. And instead of asking what any worldly leader would normally give preference to, he demanded the following 
2Chr1:7-"give me wisdom and knowledge, and I shall go forth before this people and come in, for who will be able to judge this great people of Yours? And God said to Solomon, "Since this was in your heart, and you did not request riches, possessions, and honour, neither have you requested the life of your enemies, nor have you requested many days, but you have requested for yourself wisdom and knowledge, that you should judge My people, over whom I have enthroned you. And wisdom and knowledge are granted you, and riches, possessions, and honour I shall grant you, such as that the kings before you did not possess, and which will not be so after you." 
1Kings10:23-4"Now King Solomon transcended all the kings of the earth in affluence and wisdom. And all the [inhabitants of] the earth sought Solomon's presence to hear the wisdom with which God had endowed him".

As a final note, one shouldnt be surprised at seeing all types of sins, particularly idolatry, which just so happens to be the major sin the Israelites repeatedly committed, being attributed to the Biblical prophets. It is a common theme in the Bible that the many divine chastisements that befell the Israelites were due to sins which they were mislead into commiting by their own prophets, leaders, kings. This is besides the rampant tribal prejudice running all through their history, the pueril vilification of characters and the internal conflicts. It is also worthwhile mentioning the tribal tension surrounding the Davidic line. Solomon is thus someone that broke God's covenant, and at the instigation of his hundreds of foreign polytheistic wives (700) and concubines (300) 
1Kings11"went after Ashtoreth, the goddess of the Zidonians and after Milcom the abomination of the Ammonites. And Solomon did what was displeasing to the Lord, and he was not completely devoted to the Lord as was David his father. Then did Solomon build a high place for Chemosh, the abomination of Moab on the mountain that is before Jerusalem and for Molech, the abomination of the children of Ammon". 
His multiple marriages were also a transgression of the Torah Deut17:17,Neh13:26.

After Solomon's death, his kingdom was divided, allegedly as a divine punishment for his sins, including the sin of idolatry which eventually dragged the entire nation. We see here how the divine justice plays out, punishing others for someone else's crime. Most certainly, far from that noble prophet being the instigator of this greatest sin and the cause of its re-introduction into the Israelites' lives, this yet again confirms the nation's constant and stubborn ingratitude. Moses had foreseen their turning away from the straight path into the sin of idolatry. Virtually all prophets that followed him kept on condemning them for that constant fall out into the ways of the pagan nations. 

This lack of faith resulted in them majoritarly defecting from the house of David and the divine covenant itself. The nation split in 2; the kingdom of Israel to the north with Samaria for capital and the rebellious and polytheist Jeroboam as its king, and the tiny kingdom of Judah, comprised of the tribes of Judah, Benjamin and Levi, who had remained faithful to David and Solomon's royal line, with Jerusalem as capital to the south and Solomon's son Rehoboam as king
 Hos12:1"Ephraim has surrounded me with lies, and the house of Israel with deceit, but Judah still rules with God, and with the Holy One he is faithful". 
Both kingdoms remained at war with one another throughout their respective leaders' reigns.

It certainly isnt difficult to imagine how this inter tribal hatred resulted in the kind of insidious accusations as David, Solomon and other prophets were victims of. The Hebrew Bible is literally filled with such examples. 


Further reading: